As a die-hard Red Dead fan who's spent countless hours roaming the Wild West, I can't help but chuckle at the sheer enigma that is the Strange Man. Seriously, who is this guy? A cosmic cowboy? A time-traveling trickster? Or just Rockstar's way of messing with our heads? 🤔 In both Red Dead Redemption and its sequel, he's been this shadowy figure who pops up like a bad penny, reminding us that our choices have consequences. Fast forward to 2025, and with Red Dead Redemption 3 rumored to be in the works (or maybe already out—come on, Rockstar, spill the beans!), leaving him out would be like serving beans without bacon. A total travesty! Why, you ask? Well, let's saddle up and explore why this mysterious stranger deserves a front-row seat in the next installment.

Who Is This Dapper Enigma Anyway?

Let's face it, the Strange Man isn't your average NPC. He's got this eerie vibe that makes you question reality itself. I mean, how does he know things about John Marston's past that even John forgot? That's not just good memory—that's supernatural! And remember that final encounter in the first game where bullets just bounced off him? Talk about cheat codes! 😂 It's like he's playing 4D chess while we're stuck with checkers. But is he good or evil? Nah, he's more like a moral referee, testing players with tasks that force us to confront our own dark sides. For instance, in Red Dead Redemption 2, his cabin changes based on Arthur's choices—a painting that shifts like a mood ring. Creepy, right? And don't get me started on the Armadillo theories. Some fans swear he cursed the town with cholera, while others think he made a shady deal with Herbert Moon. Honestly, it's all speculation, but that's what makes him so darn fascinating. Could he be death? Fate? Or maybe just God in a fancy hat? The possibilities are endless, and that's why we need answers in RDR3.

the-strange-man-must-return-in-red-dead-redemption-3-a-gamer-s-plea-image-0

Why Rumors Aren't Enough—We Need Face Time!

Alright, Rockstar, listen up: if you think dropping a few hints about the Strange Man in RDR3 will satisfy us, think again. Fans have been dissecting every pixel of his existence for years, with YouTube theories piling up faster than tumbleweeds in a dust storm. 🎮 Just referencing him? That's like teasing a steak dinner and serving crumbs. We need to talk to the man himself! After all, RDR3 is likely set before RDR2 (since Jack Marston isn't exactly fan-favorite material, and the Wild West era was winding down). The Strange Man was already lurking in Armadillo back then, so he fits the timeline perfectly. Plus, with Rockstar reusing maps in past games, why not bring him back physically? Here's a quick list of why mere whispers won't cut it:

  • Fan Demand: Over 72% of critics and players agree—his absence would spark outrage. (Yes, I made that stat up, but you get the point!)

  • Moral Depth: His cryptic comments challenge our ethics. Without him, the game loses its philosophical punch.

  • Theories Galore: Leaving him out would fuel wild conspiracies, like him being an alien or a glitch in the matrix. Let's avoid that chaos!

He's Obsessed with Dutch's Gang—And We Love It!

Now, here's the juicy part: the Strange Man has a thing for the Van der Linde Gang. He's like their stalker fanboy, showing up whenever a member is on the path to redemption. Remember John's encounters? They weren't random—he knew secrets John had buried deep. And in RDR2, his cabin was filled with notes about Arthur, proving he's been watching for ages. If RDR3 features Lyle Morgan (as many theories suggest), it's only logical that the Strange Man shifts his gaze to the next protagonist. Why? Because he's the ultimate observer, pushing characters to face their demons. Picture this: a table comparing his roles across games:

Game Character Observed Strange Man's Role Impact
RDR1 John Marston Tests morality, reveals forgotten past Forces redemption
RDR2 Arthur Morgan Changes art based on choices, watches from shadows Highlights consequences
RDR3 (2025) Likely Lyle Morgan ??? We need direct interaction! Could deepen the lore

He's always around the gang, and in 2025, with RDR3 potentially exploring their origins, his presence is non-negotiable. Rockstar, don't hide him—let him shine!

the-strange-man-must-return-in-red-dead-redemption-3-a-gamer-s-plea-image-1

The Risks of Skipping Him: More Mad Theories!

Imagine if RDR3 drops the ball and only mentions the Strange Man in passing. Disaster! 😱 It would unleash a tsunami of fan theories, turning him into a meme rather than a meaningful character. We've already got enough strangeness—like that time he appeared next to a flying machine mission. Bringing him back isn't just about fan service; it's about resolving a narrative arc that's been dangling since 2010. His role embodies the game's core themes: fate vs. free will, violence, and redemption. Without him, the experience feels incomplete. Plus, in 2025, players expect depth, not half-baked references. So, Rockstar, give us that face-to-face chat. Let him challenge our morals again. After all, isn't that what makes Red Dead so unforgettable? 🤠 In conclusion, leaving out the Strange Man would be like robbing a bank and forgetting the gold. Don't do it—bring him back, and let's unravel this mystery together!